| Platinum | U.S. Pizza Co |
| Gold | Shotgun Dan's Pizza - Little Rock |
| Silver | Vino's |
| Bronze | Damgoode Pies |
| Top Pick | Buenos Aires Grill and Cafe |
| Top Pick | Certified Pies |
| Top Pick | Loca Luna |
| Top Pick | Raduno Brick Oven & Barroom |
| Top Pick | The Pizza Cafe West |
| Top Pick | The Pizzeria |