| Platinum | Faded Rose Restaurant |
| Gold | Gadwall's Grill |
| Silver | Loca Luna |
| Bronze | Homers East Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Big Orange |
| Top Pick | Homer's West |
| Top Pick | Morgan's Kitchen and Deli |
| Top Pick | PK Grills |
| Top Pick | Rosie's Pot & Kettle Cafe |
| Top Pick | The Purple Cow Restaurant |
| Chili's Grill & Bar |